Tesla could be getting a big payday. New emissions rules in Europe have placed automakers under intense pressure to reduce fleet emissions or face substantial fines. To comply, companies like Ford, Toyota, Stellantis, and Mazda are pooling with Tesla, an all-electric manufacturer that far exceeds the stringent targets.
Pooling allows automakers to average out emissions, essentially buying carbon credits from Tesla to offset their shortcomings. This arrangement could net Tesla an estimated $1 billion in compensation this year, according to UBS analysts.
Tesla
Related: 2024’s best-selling cars: Who came out on top?
Tesla’s lucrative regulatory credits business
Tesla has long profited from selling regulatory credits to other automakers. In the third quarter of 2024 alone, the company made $739 million from this practice. Despite predictions that this revenue stream would decline as rivals ramp up EV production, tepid demand for electric vehicles has kept Tesla in a dominant position.
European automakers are required to ensure at least 20% of their fleet consists of EVs to meet emissions targets. However, a rollback of subsidies in key markets across Europe has dampened consumer interest, leaving many brands struggling to hit their goals. For companies falling short, pooling with Tesla has become a practical — if costly — solution to avoid steep fines.
Tesla
Failing to meet emissions targets carries a hefty price: $105 for every gram of CO₂ over the limit. These penalties can quickly escalate into hundreds of millions of dollars, making pooling agreements a financial lifeline for automakers who need to buy time to scale their EV production.
Related: Concern for Maserati grows as Stellantis Italy production plunges
Challenges loom for Tesla’s credit business
While the current setup is a windfall for Tesla, changes on the horizon could disrupt this revenue stream. The incoming U.S. administration, led by President-elect Donald Trump, has signaled plans to roll back emissions regulations and EV incentives. Analysts warn this could cost Tesla up to $3.2 billion in lost credits and subsidies.
In Europe, automakers are frustrated with the stringent rules, arguing that the aggressive timelines don’t account for economic uncertainties and consumer hesitation toward EV adoption. The 2035 mandate to phase out combustion engines has come under scrutiny, as high costs and limited charging infrastructure continue to hinder the transition to electric vehicles.
Tesla
Meanwhile, Tesla may face increasing competition in the credit market as other automakers improve their EV output. Brands like Volvo and Polestar, which have already formed their own emissions pools, are expected to capture a growing share of the regulatory credit market.
Final thoughts
For now, Tesla’s dominance in the EV market gives it leverage over rivals, turning emissions regulations into a billion-dollar payday. As automakers grapple with shifting consumer demand and regulatory pressures, Tesla’s role as a credit seller underscores the growing pains of the industry’s transition to electric mobility.
Whether Tesla can sustain this advantage in the face of evolving regulations and a changing market remains uncertain, but for now, it’s a lucrative position to be in.
Related: Japanese woman returns beloved RX-7 to Mazda after 25 years
